• 0 Posts
  • 64 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 14th, 2023

help-circle














  • Right. A modder’s work is useless without the game because it modifies someone else’s work.

    A modder takes someone else’s work and modifies it for their own purposes. Here, a company took a modder’s work, which was based off their own work, and used it for their own purposes.

    Should they be paid for it? Yes, I think so. Will they? I dunno, sounds like they removed it pretty quick.

    The only point I’m trying to make is that they both used someone else’s work without permission. (I’m assuming the modder didn’t have permission because it’s EA)




  • Nope. I know that the modders didn’t do the original work, that’s why it’s called modding.

    Most companies don’t support this practice.

    Yes, you can do whatever you want with files on your hard drive, but you’re still modding someone else’s work.

    That’s all I’m saying. Everyone is griping that the company used the modder’s work without permission, when the modder did the exact same thing: using someone else’s work without permission.

    I’m not saying modding is morally wrong - I’m something of a mod enjoyer myself XD - and I agree it’s a dick move to swipe a modder’s work, but I doubt there’s a legal leg to stand on when their work is based on an IP they don’t own.

    I do also understand the difference between small modders doing something for fun based on something they love instead of money and a company swiping someone’s work for profit.

    But it’s right there in the name. Modding. What are you modding? Someone else’s work.