cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/54697697
For years people have been like, “Hank, YouTube is so messed up, why don’t you start a competitor” and while a lot of folks have made things I love like Nebula and Dropout that are asking “OK, how do we do things differently” I didn’t feel much need to try and make something until I started watching how YouTube works for kids.
ClockwiseTV is a media platform for 6 to 12 year olds with two major decisions baked in:
- All of the content is curated by human parents.
- Every session begins with setting the stop time. It never shows a video that will go over that time and when they time is up the app closes.
Kids youtube is pretty vile.
I work in mental health and when clients bang the keyboard randomly as a small child might, the search results come back with nothing but shady ai kidslop videos called stuff like “ssssssssssddf”, “llllkkkkkjjjjhhhh”, etc.
I caught my mom playing some of that shit for my youngest one day. it was like some kind of psychedelic brainwashing shit that was just repeating logos for major brands in different colors while some AI voice kept saying the names in different speeds/pitches.
I reminded her we don’t give the kids YouTube because they act out. she didn’t believe me until her laptop died in the middle of a video he was watching and he started hitting her (he was 4). so yeah, no more YouTube.
Children should not be on YouTube
All of 6-12? None of them shall have magic-school-bus reruns?
that’s why you download them.
my kids don’t get YouTube because they become insufferable twats after 30 minutes of access.
the way YouTube functions, its features, the content, everything; it scrambles their brains and turns them into uncontrollable spastic little monsters.
no YouTube for kids.
I watched the video a few days ago, and this seems really interesting. I currently don’t let either of my kids on YouTube or YouTube adjacent shows (outside of Ms. Rachel and Danny Go).
Definitely something my older kid would interested in, I think.
deleted by creator
Shouldn’t this just be a professionally moderated peertube instance? Motherfucker wants to charge $7/mo. for access to content “curated by human parents.”
software isn’t free to write, as well as paying content creators for their content.
besides, peertube lacks the parental features he’s built into his platform.
Shouldn’t this just be a professionally moderated peertube instance
Even if people curate the content for free, there are costs associated with hosting etc. Video is expensive.
I would prefer that he pays people to do that admin work though. I imagine a lot of parents would prefer to pay someone to ensure their kids have a safe online experience, rather than relying on something free for the principle of it
Sure! But those curators and admins need to have some qualification beyond, “having a kid.”
True yes, I agree
Even if people curate the content for free, there are costs associated with hosting etc. Video is expensive.
Yes, that’s why bittorrent is famously a costly subscription service.
Yeahhhh all those parents who want to host torrents to make that possible
Hank Green is kinda dumb but this is a fine idea in principle. Parents are also kinda dumb, so I’m not sure “curated by human parents” is the flex he thinks it is.
EDIT: This comment was reported for being mean.
Given his history of passing LLM slop as his own content, I would not trust this either.
How do you know your comment was reported?
Reports go to admins on each instance involved, even if the report involves that admin.
Ahh. Didn’t know you were an admin.






