I’ve said it twice now, the “art” is the browser as a whole. The LLM is nothing more than a canvas. Each butchered rendering of a page is a performance.
And the message is the exact same one you keep bringing up - that LLMs are wasteful noise machines.
There is a lot more to art than things that make us happy, this is one of those that doesn’t. You said it yourself, it makes you feel sorrow, that in of itself makes it art.
I do not understand you, sorry. The person did not develop the LLM algorithm, and has no clue how it works, I believe, or what includes its initial dataset it trained on with.
At this point, you could claim a result of Markov’s chain a poem, would you?
It’s not art. It’s a ridiculous mockery of such a miracle as art, and I have no idea what you’re trying to state here.
Your examples are not even related to the case, at all. My feelings are not about the result of LLM as fear, scream etc., but its initial use defined as art and, sometimes even understandingly published so that the listener had no idea it was generated in 5 seconds and no actual human was involved or put any kind of personality or effort into, which is ridiculous and nonsense to consider anything but noise.
I’ve said it twice now, the “art” is the browser as a whole. The LLM is nothing more than a canvas. Each butchered rendering of a page is a performance.
And the message is the exact same one you keep bringing up - that LLMs are wasteful noise machines.
There is a lot more to art than things that make us happy, this is one of those that doesn’t. You said it yourself, it makes you feel sorrow, that in of itself makes it art.
Brutalism makes me uncomfortable, its still art: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutalist_architecture
The Scream is deliberately designed to make you feel dread, it is art: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scream
Horror movies are the same.
I do not understand you, sorry. The person did not develop the LLM algorithm, and has no clue how it works, I believe, or what includes its initial dataset it trained on with.
At this point, you could claim a result of Markov’s chain a poem, would you?
It’s not art. It’s a ridiculous mockery of such a miracle as art, and I have no idea what you’re trying to state here.
Your examples are not even related to the case, at all. My feelings are not about the result of LLM as fear, scream etc., but its initial use defined as art and, sometimes even understandingly published so that the listener had no idea it was generated in 5 seconds and no actual human was involved or put any kind of personality or effort into, which is ridiculous and nonsense to consider anything but noise.
The LLM by itself is not the art, the browser system the developer created is.
A blank canvas by itself isn’t art, the painting created on it is.