This site gathers several popular monspace programming fonts, and puts them in a randomized bracket anonymously. You choose your favorite in each matchup, then at the end you find out which ones you ranked highest.
(I didn’t create this and am not affiliated, I just saw it a while back and I think it’s neat.)
Looks like IBM Plex Mono is my “winner”, but they didn’t have Consolas in the blind bracket for it to come up against.
Ah, I guess because it’s a Microsoft thing. Inconsolata is probably supposed to be there as its alternative, does it come close?