talking to tire someone out is not Gish gallop.

So you don’t understand the term.

here:

The Gish gallop (/ˈɡɪʃ ˈɡæləp/) is a rhetorical technique in which a person in a debate attempts to overwhelm an opponent by presenting an excessive number of arguments, with no regard for their accuracy or strength, with a rapidity that makes it impossible for the opponent to address them in the time available.

so the RSPCA would have zero issue with a cat on a vegan diet as long as the cat had adequate nutrition and was eating palatable food.

any argument with that?

nope.

if the animal has nutritious food and enjoys the food then the RSPCA would be fine.

the RSPCA published the following information:

it is possible to develop a plant-based diet for cats, these need to be carefully formulated to meet the unique nutritional requirements of the cat and be appropriately supplemented with essential nutrients

Gish gallop is a series of untrue statements said in rapid fire that the other person does not have time to refute.

you don’t understand the word.

I don’t think you know what this means.

we talk about gremlins in a system.

bwg is a Welsh word that has come to mean creepy crawly, but also means spooky ghosty.

you would not have to. An animal living in nature is exempt.

funny!

If you lived on an island where there was plentiful nutritious food that did not cause suffering, where there were health benefits to eating the vegetable options and where there were vegetable options that tasted similar to meat, would you still continue to eat meat?

potentially. I have no idea what this means.

But if the vegan cat biscuits are enjoyed by a cat and are nutritious, then would you have any issues with it?

so if the cats enjoy the food and the food is nutritious you would be against it?

but what if they did enjoy eating the biscuits? Would you knock the food out of their mouths?

this is a very emotive issue. apparently cats have to consent to everything. and their life with humans must be 100% natural. otherwise it is animal abuse.

no. we both agree. the food needs to be both nutritional.and palatable. then there is no issue.

but if someone who understood it better than us agreed that the food was nutritional and the cat enjoyed the flavour you would be fine with it?

if the animal enjoys the food and it has all the nutrition the animal needs then how is it torture?.

Do you also rant at people who keep their cats inside against their will?

are you a vet or a nutritional scientist by any chance?

So as long as the cat is happy eating the food and has nutrition it’s really not a problem.

I’m not a vet or a scientist. but these issues are easy to solve.